Proposed research project title
Impacts of the cost of living and housing crisis on the social services sector workforce
Description of lead organisation
Catholic Social Services Victoria (CSSV) is the peak body for Catholic social services across the state. Underpinned by Catholic Social Teaching, we work with our 40+ member organisations, to assist the Catholic bishops and broader Catholic community across Victoria, to fulfil the gospel imperatives to stand with and serve the poor, disadvantaged and marginalised, and to work for a just, equitable and compassionate society. Together our member organisations support over 300,000 people per year.
Existing relationship with ACU
CSSV has a strong existing relationship with ACU in numerous ways.
CSSV previously partnered with ACU via SESU to undertake the research report Scarring Effects of the Pandemic Economy, released in 2022, written with Dr. Tom Barnes. We co-launched this report with a panel of leaders within social services, held a number of briefings, and organised MP visits as a result of this report together with ACU.
ACU has generously sponsored a number of CSSV events in recent years, including the National Catholic Social Services Conference in early 2024, and the upcoming CSSV Annual Dinner to be held in August 2025.
CSSV's ED will be presenting a paper at the upcoming ACU conference Idol Talk? In the Image of the Disabled God Disability, the Imago Dei and Practical Consequences.
CSSV continues to appreciate the opportunities and expert knowledge and capacity for collaboration with ACU and sees strong synergies in our mission and values.
Context of the research project
One of the lynch pins of the Victorian Government's 10 year housing plan is the creation of 'affordable housing'. This housing is ill-defined, and as it stands, likely out of the reach of low paid workers, some of whom work within aged care, early childhood education and care, and in support roles within social services.
Broader workforce challenges in the social and community services sector have been identified by both government and service providers in recent years. The CSSV Strategic Planning Member Survey results showed that workforce challenges were consistently
raised as a significant issue facing Catholic social service providers in Victoria over the next five years.
With cost of living and housing affordability front of mind for many, it is important to consider how these factors may be impacting on the experience of social service workers, and the implications for wider recruitment and retention, given lower rates of pay in the sector. It is sobering to consider that much of the housing that is currently defined as 'affordable' by Government may in fact be out of reach for many workers in our sector.
Essential workers have been identified as a key focus group in affordable housing supply, but the Victorian Government has a narrow working definition of 'essential' workers, which currently does not include social and community services workers (eg. Regional Worker Accommodation Fund). A recent meeting with the Australian Services Union Vic/Tas highlighted this concern. The ASU expressed that they do not have good information of the impacts of housing and associated aggregate salaries of social services staff which makes targeted advocacy on this issue difficult, although anecdotally from our sector there are reports of housing stress and movement/attrition from the sector due to a lack of secure/affordable housing options for workers given their income/wage.
Proposed research questions
How many workers in our member organisations are paid in the lower-moderate income bracket? Could this be extrapolated across the social services sector more broadly?
How is the cost of living and housing crisis impacting the Catholic social services sector?
Are social service workers able to access affordable housing within a reasonable distance of their workplace?
In a sector that has limited salary potential, what are the motivating factors for workforce participation? Do these factors relate to organisational mission and values?
Objectives of the research
To collect data on aggregated salary information across the Catholic social services sector, so we can understand whether 'affordable' housing is affordable for them.
To survey Catholic social services staff about their housing costs and concerns, so as to determine the impact of the housing crisis on this cohort and their livelihoods.
To survey staff about their intentions to remain in the sector and what factors influence this decision.
Anticipated outcomes and outputs
A public facing report that includes the baseline aggregated data that relates lower paid social services workforce and their futures in our sector with existing housing policy, which can then be used to advocate for better definitions of affordable housing in Victoria, with possible application across the country.
The report could assist workforce planning and advocacy for further/other supports required to ensure the wellbeing of staff, and therefore the ongoing ability for social services to be effectively delivered in difficult times.
The report may find that working for a Catholic/values based organisation is meaningful in assisting staff to make sacrifices of higher salaries in other sectors, which demonstrate a strength of faith based organisations.
A series of meetings with relevant state and federal Ministers and Members of Parliament to advocate for policies that support the needs of lower-moderate income earners in the social services sector.
This report could see unions and employers working together for a common goal, which does not happen much in the social services sector.
How many people do you anticipate the research will benefit?
The Catholic social services sector in Victoria includes over 7,500 staff supporting over 300,000 people (Faith, Hope and Love: Mapping and contextualising the contributions of Victoria's Catholic social services sector, 2024). This research would support advocacy for the wellbeing of these workers, particularly those with lower incomes (eg. aged care and disability workers).
Organisations' anticipated timeframe
We anticipate the research project will be carried out over a period of 12 months:
Phase 1: Working with researchers to further define research parameters and engage partner organisations from within CSSV's membership base - 4 months
Phase 2: Data collection (aggregated salary information and staff surveys) - 2 months
Phase 3: Collation and analysis of data and development of research report - 3 months
Phase 4: Dissemination and advocacy (report launch, meetings, briefings) - 3 months
Existing data
CSSV does not itself collect relevant data, however it's 40+ member organisations have salary related data they have indicated they could make available. From initial discussions with members., aggregate data could be made available for the project. Broad endorsement has been received for this proposal from the CSSV Council, which is made up of six elected members from across the CSSV membership base, as well as the CSSV Policy/Advocacy/Research Committee which draws its membership from the larger organisations policy teams.
Involvement of Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander people
This research relates to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as employees of Catholic social service organisations.
CSSV is not, nor are any of our members, an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander controlled organisation.
CSSV member organisations include the Aboriginal Catholic Ministry Victoria, and many of our members partner with and provide support to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities and organisations including MacKillop Family Services, Jesuit Social Services, Edmund Rice Community Services etc.
Involvement of minors
No.
Organisations' project lead, expertise and their desired support from ACU
Project Lead Nominee: Josh Lourensz
CSSV brings a diverse network of member organisations and sector relationships to this project which will be beneficial in developing collaborative partnerships. CSSV's experience in partnering for the Scarring Effects SESU research project places us well in working with ACU and our members to gather data and ensure productive working relationships at an aggregate level. CSSV is comprised of a small but dedicated team who offer capacity in delivering on project requirements.
Josh is the Executive Director and CSSV has commissioned research and co-designed questions with a number of researchers and academics. This project has the support of the CSSV Policy/Advocacy/Research Committee who have a range of research backgrounds and skills.
Skills or expertise CSSV is seeking assistance with from ACU:
Quantitative data analytical skills
Survey design
Familiarity with policy and legislative documents
Interest in housing and/or sector workforce issues
In-kind contributions from the organisations
Rather CSSV would be looking to activate its member organisations, along with potentially the Australian Services Union Vic/Tas for data contributions. CSSV has trusted and respected relationships with our member organisations due to a track record of consistent, meaningful work, so we are confident that aggregate data and a staff survey will be rolled out in collaboration.
Proposed partner agencies
VMCH: https://vmch.com.au/
MacKillop Family Services: https://www.mackillop.org.au/
CatholicCare Victoria: https://www.catholiccarevic.org.au/
St John of God Accord: https://accorddisability.sjog.org.au/
Sacred Heart Mission: https://www.sacredheartmission.org/
Good Shepherd Australia New Zealand: https://goodshep.org.au/
Jesuit Social Services: https://jss.org.au/
VincentCare: https://www.vincentcare.org.au/
Assisi Centre: https://assisicentre.com.au/
Nazareth House: https://nazarethcare.com.au/locations/camberwell/
CSSV intends to partner with a number of our member organisations on this research project. As a peak body, CSSV has 40+ members, with an overall staff base of 7500 people, and strong and trusted relationships with our members. Recruitment and retention of staff is an ongoing challenge in the social services sector, as well as broad commitment to the issue of housing generally, so understanding and addressing housing affordability as a key aspect of enabling a stable workforce is vital for these organisations.
This project has received broad initial endorsement from our members by going through internal processes. There would need to be further development of the research questions prior to pitching the exact data requests, and survey circulation, across members. From initial conversations and responses, there has been positive support.
Recommendations from the SESU Advisory Group
If the project involves First Nations communities, the project may be classed as 'higher risk' from a research ethics perspective.
Collection of demographic and salary data potentially from marginalised/vulnerable populations is proposed. Aggregated data can be provided however, consent for third party use is unconfirmed.